Talossan RISK game

[Ian Plätschisch]

Oct 6, 2016 16:33:02 GMT -6 Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H. said:

Here is what I propose:

Roll	Inferior Forces	1:1	3:2	2:1	3:1	4:1
8 (6 on SH)	200% Damage	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction
7 (5 on SH)	100% Damage	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction
6 (4 on SH)	50% Damage	50% Damage	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction
5 (3 on SH)	25% Damage	25% Damage	50% Damage	Total Destruction	Total Destruction	Total Destruction
4 (2 on SH)	No Effect	10% Damage	25% Damage	50% Damage	Total Destruction	Total Destruction
3 (1 on SH)	No Effect	No Effect	10% Damage	25% Damage	25% Damage	Total Destruction
2	No Effect	No Effect	No Effect	10% Damage	10% Damage	10% Damage
1	No Effect	No Effect	No Effect	No Effect	No Effect	No Effect

Brilliant!  A bit hard to digest, but I believe I understand it more after looking at the example

To be clear, the possibilities for rolling a 7 and 8 are only available to a player defending from a stronghold (therefore the attacking damage information for these numbers is unnecessary).

Also, are ratios always rounded in the defender's favor?

[Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.]

Oct 6, 2016 17:55:26 GMT -6 Ian Plätschisch said:

Brilliant!  A bit hard to digest, but I believe I understand it more after looking at the example

Thanks!

To be clear, the possibilities for rolling a 7 and 8 are only available to a player defending from a stronghold (therefore the attacking damage information for these numbers is unnecessary).

Yes, indeed... I was just keeping the format stable. It is indeed impossible to roll a natural 7 or 8 on a 6 sided dice.

Also, are ratios always rounded in the defender's favor?

No, they are always rounded down. You are in the inferior number unless you have equal or more. Then you are at 1:1 until you are 50% higher (3:2). When you are double, it's 2:1, and so one for 3:1 and 4:1.

Did I round weirdly in my examples?

[Ian Plätschisch]

Thanks for clarifying (you didn't round weirdly, I just wanted to make sure)

I guess the extra 7 and 8 stats could be relevant if an attacker attacked a larger force defending from a stronghold (which is possible, so it should be left in, but I don't know why anyone would do that)

Is loss of troops always rounded down as well?

[Alèx Soleighlfred]

Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.

I propose the following. We continue this game as it is, in the meantime we accumulate ideas and questions about possible better rulings, and after the game we hold a discussion upon which we collectively accept Third Edition of rules.

Also, I will now hand Gamemastership over to you. I'm deadly short of time. I will also send you the biggest version of the current map.

[Alèx Soleighlfred]

TURN 3, ACTION PLAN REVEALING

---

SERESA

1. R Uni, 20; Yakke, 5; Rax, 10; Sat, 7
2. S: -Uni
3. S: +Durtu
4. M: Unn » Mitt, 6
5. M: Mitt » Uni, 7
6. Q: Uni » (east), 26 [Ardatic]
7. Q: Ardatic » (east), 25 [Xurn]
8. Q: Xurn » (east), 24 [Solou]
9. Q: Solou » (southeast), 23 [Riannon]
10. Q: Riannon » (east), 22 [Nurre]

TERMINUS

1. R: 1D, 18; 2D, 18
2. Q: 2D >> (west), 24 [3A]
3. Q: 3A >> (west), 23 [3B]
4. Q: 3B >> (west), 22 [3C]
5. Q: 3C >> (northwest), 21 [3D]
6. Q: 1D >> (northwest), 22 [3E]
7. Q: 3E >> (north), 21 [3F]
8. Q: 3F >> (north), 20 [3G]
9. Q: 3G >> (north), 19 [3H]
10. Q: 3H >> (north), 18 [3i]

TALC

1. C WTX
2. R Texas 18,Kemal, 5, E6, 20, E7 8, plus the 1 unit for Texas, Rocky, Kemal, Main, Shard, NWT, WTX and ATL for being around my capital.
3 .S E7
4 .S Maine
5 .S. Castle Black
6. S. Shard
7. Q. E6 >> (North East) 12 [Hole]
8. Q. E6 >> (North West) 3 [SS]
9. Q. Hole >> East 12 [CSW]
10. Q CSW >> South 12 [E8, currently Mg]


NEW CÉZEMBRE

1. R: Mg, 66 (+Capital area reinforcement)
2. Q: Mg >> (North) ,10 [Al]
3. S: +Mg
4. Q: Al >> (North) ,9 [Si]
5. Q: Si >> (West) ,8 [ P]
6. Q: P >> (West-NorthWest) ,20 [ S]
7. Q: S >> (West) ,20 [Cl]
8. Q: Cl >> (West) ,20 [Ar]
9. Q: Ar >> (West-Northwest) ,20 [K]
10. Q: K >> Shard ,20

Explanation: As the current Gamemaster, I have put my action plan first (I was first in Turn 1, last in Turn 2 and first now. GM will be last in Turn 4.) As Terminus didn't revise his action plan and New Cezembre with TALC did, I put Terminus second. As TALC has sent their revised plan 1 hour earlier than New Cezembre, TALC was put third, and New Cezembre fourth.

From this moment on I officially delegate my Gamemastership to Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H..

[Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.]

Can you publish the battle results and the map?

[Alèx Soleighlfred]

Oct 7, 2016 3:30:38 GMT -6 Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H. said:

Can you publish the battle results and the map?

I didn't coudln't resolve anything. i sent u hi-res map and it's up to you for the time being

[Deleted]

Not to intrude, but uhhh.... Can I join the next game, supposing I become a citizen?

[Alèx Soleighlfred]

I personally don't see a reason why you'd not be able to participate in current one. Only you'll have a big disadvantage of late registration.

[Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.]

Alex, I can't access Turn2's map!!! I need it to make turn 3!!!

[Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.]

According to me, the Phase 2 results were: talossa.ca/risk/phase2.png

I will base on this for phase 3 resolution.

[Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.]

This is Phase 3, but with only the Blue and Green players resolved.

Don't hesitate to point out errors..

talossa.ca/risk/phase3.png

[Glüc da Dhi]

There are some differences between the two maps, but Im on my phone now with a bad wifi connection so Im not sure I can send it to you.

[Marti-Pair Furxheir S.H.]

Phase 3 is now resolved.

www.talossa.ca/risk/phase3.png

I obviously lost the attack with 12 units of MG (which has 57 and a SH), but I won the Attack of P with 3 units VS only 1. I rolled 11, and I rolled a 5 for Gluc.

Shard was an automatic victory for Gluc, as was what is now CSW.

I will calculate the reinforcements later today.

Oh, look, I survived another round! Yeah!

[Glüc da Dhi]

I have to post against my own interests here. I didnt automatically win shard. I had far fewer troops going in there giving me only a slight advantage which will have to be settled using dice